| Contest | Day | Prediction | Winner | Score |
| SpC2k4 | 2 | Metroid over Pac-Man with 68.45% | Metroid with 68.51% | 49.94 |
| SpC2k4 | 16 | FF VI over Mortal Kombat with 73.50% | FF VI with 73.08% | 49.58 |
| SpC2k4 | 24 | Zelda: OoT over Fallout 2 with 86.80% | Zelda: OoT with 86.31% | 49.51 |
| SpC2k4 | 17 | FF VII over Suikoden II with 86.50% | FF VII with 85.63% | 49.13 |
| SC2k4 | 8 | Mario over JC Denton with 82.00% | Mario with 83.54% | 48.46 |
| SpC2k4 | 37 | Chrono Trigger over Super Mario RPG with 65.11% | Chrono Trigger with 67.06% | 48.05 |
| SC2k4 | 7 | Bowser over Guybrush with 85.00% | Bowser with 82.99% | 47.99 |
| SpC2k4 | 29 | FFTA over Fire Emblem with 68.56% | FFTA with 66.36% | 47.80 |
| SpC2k4 | 51 | Chrono Trigger over SMW with 56.70% | Chrono Trigger with 59.01% | 47.69 |
| SpC2k4 | 3 | Contra over Phantasy Star with 58.67% | Contra with 61.02% | 47.65 |
| SC2k4 | 4 | Luigi over Pac-Man with 65.00% | Luigi with 67.73% | 47.27 |
| SC2k4 | 14 | Master Chief over Crash Bandicoot with 67.80% | Master Chief with 70.72% | 47.08 |
| SC2k4 | 6 | Crono over Conker with 75.00% | Crono with 77.99% | 47.01 |
| SC2k4 | 13 | Frog over Liquid Snake with 53.20% | Frog with 50.05% | 46.85 |
| SpC2k4 | 8 | Tetris over Galaga with 81.50% | Tetris with 78.25% | 46.75 |
| SC2k4 | 3 | Yoshi over Ryo Hazuki with 73.00% | Yoshi with 76.40% | 46.60 |
| SpC2k4 | 39 | Zelda: LttP over Super Metroid with 70.53% | Zelda: LttP with 74.00% | 46.53 |
| SpC2k4 | 10 | Super Mario RPG over Street Fighter II with 59.89% | Super Mario RPG with 56.24% | 46.35 |
| SpC2k4 | 40 | FF VI over Doom with 69.03% | FF VI with 72.72% | 46.31 |
| SpC2k4 | 21 | Castlevania: SotN over Perfect Dark with 56.90% | Castlevania: SotN with 53.18% | 46.28 |
| SC2k4 | 11 | Vercetti over Max Payne with 58.00% | Vercetti with 61.96% | 46.04 |
| SpC2k4 | 13 | Zelda: LttP over Gunstar Heroes with 86.99% | Zelda: LttP with 91.15% | 45.84 |
| SpC2k4 | 5 | Donkey Kong over Duck Hunt with 54.72% | Donkey Kong with 50.07% | 45.35 |
| SpC2k4 | 20 | MGS over Resident Evil with 75.40% | MGS with 70.62% | 45.22 |
| SpC2k4 | 11 | Sonic 2 over Shining Force with 75.60% | Sonic 2 with 80.71% | 44.89 |
| SpC2k4 | 36 | Tetris over Pong with 68.33% | Tetris with 73.47% | 44.86 |
| SpC2k4 | 31 | GTA: Vice City over Star Wars: KOTOR with 65.57% | GTA: Vice City with 60.32% | 44.75 |
| SpC2k4 | 47 | FF X over FFTA with 72.10% | FF X with 66.54% | 44.44 |
| SpC2k4 | 19 | FF Tactics over DDR with 81.70% | FF Tactics with 76.03% | 44.33 |
| SpC2k4 | 46 | Zelda: WW over Metroid Prime with 60.90% | Zelda: WW with 55.22% | 44.32 |
| SpC2k4 | 9 | Chrono Trigger over Secret of Mana with 85.12% | Chrono Trigger with 79.39% | 44.27 |
| SC2k4 | 2 | Ganondorf over Alucard with 63.00% | Ganondorf with 57.16% | 44.16 |
| SpC2k4 | 50 | Legend of Zelda over Tetris with 68.70% | Legend of Zelda with 74.57% | 44.13 |
| SpC2k4 | 12 | SMW over The Simpsons with 75.60% | SMW with 81.47% | 44.13 |
| SpC2k4 | 30 | FF X over Shenmue with 80.53% | FF X with 74.48% | 43.95 |
| SpC2k4 | 44 | Zelda: OoT over SM 64 with 70.00% | Zelda: OoT with 76.26% | 43.74 |
| SpC2k4 | 35 | Legend of Zelda over Donkey Kong with 80.64% | Legend of Zelda with 87.04% | 43.60 |
| SC2k4 | 9 | MM over Earthworm Jim with 90.00% | MM with 82.98% | 42.98 |
| SC2k4 | 5 | Magus over Luca Blight with 74.00% | Magus with 81.04% | 42.96 |
| SpC2k4 | 49 | SMB 3 over Final Fantasy with 52.10% | SMB 3 with 59.60% | 42.50 |
| SpC2k4 | 6 | Legend of Zelda over Adventure with 87.43% | Legend of Zelda with 95.20% | 42.23 |
| SpC2k4 | 23 | SM 64 over NiGHTS into dreams with 76.90% | SM 64 with 84.83% | 42.07 |
| SpC2k4 | 48 | SSBM over GTA: Vice City with 62.80% | SSBM with 53.54% | 40.74 |
| SpC2k4 | 27 | Zelda: WW over Skies of Arcadia with 84.55% | Zelda: WW with 74.71% | 40.16 |
| SpC2k4 | 34 | Final Fantasy over Contra with 80.04% | Final Fantasy with 70.05% | 40.01 |
| SpC2k4 | 38 | SMW over Sonic 2 with 60.30% | SMW with 70.57% | 39.73 |
| SC2k4 | 10 | Shadow over Tidus with 52.00% | Tidus with 50.81% | 39.38 |
| SpC2k4 | 22 | Goldeneye over Panzer Dragoon Saga with 70.10% | Goldeneye with 80.81% | 39.29 |
| SpC2k4 | 14 | Super Metroid over Phantasy Star IV with 72.34% | Super Metroid with 83.29% | 39.05 |
| SpC2k4 | 52 | FF VI over Zelda: LttP with 50.70% | Zelda: LttP with 52.66% | 38.28 |
| SpC2k4 | 1 | SMB 3 over Metal Gear with 70.23% | SMB 3 with 82.30% | 37.93 |
| SpC2k4 | 4 | Final Fantasy over Pitfall with 74.89% | Final Fantasy with 87.63% | 37.26 |
| SpC2k4 | 32 | SSBM over MGS 2 with 69.52% | SSBM with 56.72% | 37.20 |
| SpC2k4 | 7 | Pong over River City Ransom with 53.69% | Pong with 68.01% | 35.68 |
| SC2k4 | 12 | Zero over Protoman with 56.80% | Zero with 71.72% | 35.08 |
| SpC2k4 | 26 | Kingdom Hearts over SoulCalibur with 65.59% | Kingdom Hearts with 50.60% | 35.01 |
| SC2k4 | 16 | Solid Snake over Tanner with 76.00% | Solid Snake with 94.30% | 31.70 |
| SpC2k4 | 28 | Metroid Prime over Half-Life with 75.54% | Metroid Prime with 56.16% | 30.62 |
| SC2k4 | 15 | Kefka over Knuckles with 51.00% | Knuckles with 57.46% | 28.08 |
| SpC2k4 | 25 | Halo over Starcraft with 60.51% | Starcraft with 50.17% | 23.64 |
| SpC2k4 | 15 | Earthbound over Doom with 54.78% | Doom with 57.04% | 21.36 |
| SpC2k4 | 18 | Pokemon G/S/C over Xenogears with 57.90% | Xenogears with 57.95% | 13.30 |
| SpC2k4 | 45 | Kingdom Hearts over Starcraft with 63.70% | Starcraft with 53.57% | 10.46 |
